The Kitchen Tools I've Kept for Three Years

The easiest way to know what I actually use is to move. I've moved twice in three years, once across Williamsburg and once down the street and up a flight. Each time the boxes labeled "kitchen" got lighter. Not because I was purging for a blog post. Because I was tired of carrying things I didn't reach for.

What's left is short. Six tools. All of them have been in my narrow galley kitchen for at least three years, some closer to four. None of them were expensive, except one. All of them have been used in a kitchen with no dishwasher, one drawer, and counter space that measures out to about five feet if I push the kettle back.

The three-year test (and why most kitchen tools fail it)

The thing is, most kitchen gadgets don't fail loudly. They just stop getting picked. I open the drawer, my hand goes past the thing, and I reach for the knife or the spoon or the tool I already trust. Months go by. I realize the gadget has been in the way the whole time, doing nothing.

I've written before about rebuilding the kitchen from scratch: emptying the drawers, wiping them out, and only putting back what I'd actually touched in the last month. That reset is what clarified this list. These six tools made it back into the drawer the same day. Everything else waited on the counter, and most of it went to a neighbor or to the donation pile downstairs.

My filter is boring and strict. No dishwasher, so anything fussy to hand-wash is already at a disadvantage. One drawer, so shape matters. Anything with a weird silhouette has to earn the space. Renter kitchen, third-floor walkup, no power tools allowed, which rules out any tool that requires mounting or drilling. And the big one: it has to work without a second dirty dish. If using it creates more cleanup than it saves, it's gone.

Three years in, these are the ones still here.

The citrus squeezer that earned its drawer space

I'd bought three citrus squeezers before this one. Two went in the trash. The third got passed to a friend who politely never mentioned it again. So when I ordered another, I was mostly doing it because I'd run out of excuses for why my lemon water was full of seeds.

The difference with this squeezer, the citrus squeezer with seed-catching lid, is the lid. Sounds like the most obvious detail in the world, but the lid has small holes that catch seeds and pulp on the way out. Every other squeezer I'd owned assumed I'd fish the seeds out later, which, in a real kitchen, I don't. I just drank pulpy lemon water and resented the tool.

The 2-pack was the other small thing. One lives in the drawer by the stove for cooking. The other lives on the small shelf by the window where I make my morning lemon water. Sounds silly until I remember that the friction of walking three feet to retrieve a tool is often the difference between using it and not.

Three years in, I've used this squeezer probably four mornings a week and two to three times a week for cooking. Conservatively, that's over 1,000 squeezes. It still works. The one honest downside: the plastic is starting to discolor around the press point, a faint yellow-brown shadow where the citrus oils have soaked in. It still functions, but it's not pretty anymore. I'll replace it when it cracks, not before.

The mini blender that didn't get resold on Facebook Marketplace

Full-size blenders are a losing bet in a 5-foot galley kitchen. I owned one for about eight months in my first Williamsburg apartment, and the relationship was awful. It took up a quarter of my counter, it was loud enough that I couldn't use it before 8 AM without feeling like a bad neighbor, and every use created three separate dirty pieces to hand-wash. I sold it on Facebook Marketplace and swore off the category.

Then I tried the Beast Mini Blender with swappable vessels. The whole premise: blend into a small vessel, screw on a drinking lid, and leave. No pouring from pitcher to glass, no separate cup to wash. The blade housing unscrews, rinses in seconds, and that's the whole cleanup.

I've been using it for three years, mostly for morning smoothies and the occasional pesto. The extra vessels are the reason it survived. When I used one and didn't rinse it immediately because I was running out the door, there was always a clean one in the cabinet. In a no-dishwasher apartment, that buffer is what saves a tool from getting resented.

The honest downside: 600W is enough for bananas, spinach, yogurt, and soft fruit, but it will struggle with frozen fruit unless I add liquid first. I learned this by burning out the motor briefly on a block of frozen mango. It recovered. I don't do that anymore. This is not the blender for crushed ice or thick, frozen-solid smoothies.

The other downside: the vessels show their age. Mine are scratched on the inside from three years of rubber spatulas. The performance hasn't changed, but they don't look new. I can live with that.

The butter cutter I laughed at and then bought

I want to be clear: I ordered this as a joke. A friend had mentioned it, I read the product page, I laughed, I added it to my cart, and I moved on. Two weeks later I was using it every morning.

The One-Click Butter Cutter does exactly one thing: load a stick of butter into it, and it dispenses one tablespoon-ish slice at a time with a click. That's it. That's the whole product. I understand why it sounds ridiculous on paper. Here's what I didn't factor in: my butter dish used to be a mess. Crumb-dusted, fingerprinted, sliced unevenly every time because I was half-awake and cutting with a butter knife. The butter cutter just fixed that. The dish stays clean. The slices are even. The butter stays cold in the fridge instead of sweating on the counter.

Three years in, I've used it probably 800 mornings. It's plastic, yes. It's a uni-tasker, yes. I don't care. It earned its spot.

The honest downside: it only works on full-size American stick butter. European-style blocks or cubes don't fit, and whipped butter obviously isn't happening. If stick butter isn't a staple, this tool is useless. In a household that buys stick butter and eats it daily, I haven't regretted this one.

The snack tray that replaced three Tupperwares

This one snuck up on me. I bought it for a dinner party, a real one with five people in my apartment, which is basically a logistics exercise. I needed something that could hold a spread of olives, cheese, nuts, and the cut-up carrot situation I'd committed to. It did that fine. What I didn't expect was that it would then become a weeknight workhorse.

The reversible-lid snack tray has five compartments and a lid that flips. One side is a flat cover for fridge storage. The other side is a stretch lid that seals around the compartments individually, which is the move that earned it permanent space. I can prep Sunday night, seal it, and it stacks flat in my very small fridge without tipping over anything else. On a weeknight when I'm too tired to plate, I pull it out, pop the lid, and eat directly from the tray at my desk. It's not pretty. It works.

Three years in, I've done the Sunday-prep-to-weeknight-tray routine probably 120 weeks out of the 156 I've owned it. Most weeks, in other words, with gaps when I was traveling.

The stacking matters a lot in my fridge, which is the shallow apartment-standard kind with two real shelves and a lot of aspirational hope. The tray fits exactly on the middle shelf and holds the equivalent of three of the mismatched Tupperwares I used to juggle. Those Tupperwares are gone now. The tray replaced them and did a better job.

The honest downside: the product claims dishwasher-safe. I don't have a dishwasher, so I can't fully test this, but a friend who does told me the stretch lid loses grip after a dozen hot cycles. I hand-wash everything anyway, and the stretch lid on mine is still tight three years in. If a dishwasher is in the picture, I'd hand-wash this specific piece.

The tortilla crimper I use more than I expected to

Weeknight dinner in my apartment is almost always some variation of "what's in the fridge, wrapped in something." Quesadillas are in heavy rotation. For years I made them in a pan, flipping carefully, losing cheese to the burner every third attempt, and eating the half that didn't fall apart.

The adjustable tortilla quesadilla crimper is the kind of tool I would have dismissed on principle a few years ago. It's a metal press with three size settings (6, 8, and 10 inches) that crimps a tortilla into a sealed half-moon with a textured edge. I fill the tortilla, fold, crimp, and it holds its seal in the pan. No falling cheese. No exploding dumpling moment.

I've used the 8-inch setting maybe 200 times. The 6-inch has been surprisingly useful for dumplings when I've made the dough a little too thin. The 10-inch is for larger burrito-adjacent projects. The three sizes aren't a gimmick. They're the reason I still use it instead of letting it migrate to the back of the cabinet.

The honest downside: this tool doesn't override physics. Anything wetter than a standard quesadilla filling will leak. Refried beans with a lot of liquid? Leaks. Saucy chicken? Leaks. The crimp seals the edge, but it can't stop a wet filling from finding the weak point. I drain things now. That's on me.

The trash can that finally earned kitchen floor real estate

I spent most of my twenties resenting trash cans. Every one I owned was bad, either too small, too loud, with a lid that fell off, or with the kind of step-pedal that broke after six months. In a small apartment, the trash can is not a background object. It's on the floor, visible, and I use it probably 30 times a day. I was not going to put another ugly, broken thing in my kitchen.

The TOWNEW T1S self-sealing smart trash can is the most expensive thing on this list by a wide margin, and it's the one I'd replace first if it broke tomorrow. When the can is full, I tap the top, and it heat-seals the bag shut and loads a new one from an internal refill ring. That's it. No tying knots of limp plastic bags, no touching the rim of a full can.

Three years and change in, I've used it daily. The auto-seal matters more than it sounds, especially in a no-dishwasher apartment where things like meat packaging and citrus peels live in the trash and start smelling if they sit. The can seals, the smell stays in, and I swap bags only when the ring runs out, which is about every two weeks for me.

The honest downside: the refill rings are proprietary. They have to be ordered from TOWNEW. I used to buy nice scented trash bags anyway, so the cost feels roughly equivalent in my own budget. For a kitchen that runs on grocery-store liners, the math is different.

The other honest downside: it's loud when it seals. A distinct mechanical whirr-click for about four seconds. In an open-plan apartment where someone's on a call, they'll notice.

What I got rid of to make room for these

The tools that didn't survive follow a pattern. The cheap versions of things I later upgraded: the citrus squeezers I mentioned, an early silicone spatula set that warped, a pan that lost its coating in the first year. The duplicates. I used to own four mixing bowls and now own two. The single-use gadgets I was sold on once: an avocado slicer, a strawberry huller, a garlic press that was harder to clean than a knife.

I wrote up a few of the gadgets that didn't make the cut already, the ones I returned inside the 30-day window before they could embarrass me long-term. The rest just quietly left in moving boxes I never unpacked.

The point isn't that any of those tools were bad. It's that my kitchen is small, my time is finite, and the cost of a tool isn't only the money. It's the drawer space, the hand-wash minute, the mental load of another thing to reach past.

What I'd buy (or skip) if I were starting from scratch

The one I'd start with: the butter cutter. Low-risk entry, no commitment. Either it fits a daily routine or it doesn't, and I knew within a week.

On the expensive one: the TOWNEW is worth it only in a kitchen that cooks real food and generates actual kitchen trash. A household that eats out five nights a week will see the refill costs outpace the benefit. For a kitchen that cooks most nights, it's the best trash can investment I've made.

For a kitchen as tight as mine: the mini blender wins over any full-size appliance, the handheld squeezer with the seed lid wins over the countertop version, and the snack tray is only worth it if the fridge-to-table move is already part of the routine. It's a great tray, but only when it matches how a kitchen actually eats.

Three years is a long time to keep anything. These six made it.

I buy every product on this site with my own money. No sponsors, no free samples, no brand deals. Links are Amazon affiliate links — if you buy through one, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. That commission is how the site stays online. Thanks.